Have you read this book? What did you think of it?
I was fascinated by The Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother by Amy Chua from the moment I read about it in Time Magazine. I was in the midst of a series of arguments with Jesse, as well as trying to work out what homeschool approach I want to take, and the book seemed to be offering me something. I got ahold of a copy and read it last weekend.
It's about a Chinese woman who was raised in America by strict Chinese parents, married an American man, and decided to raise her children the strict Chinese way. She set out to show that the Chinese method of parenting is superior to the Western method, though in the end, I think she wasn't quite so sure. One of her daughters went along with her methods (hours of rote learning, hours of piano practise every day, no sleepovers or playdates) but her second daughter refused to comply, and the household became a battleground. In the end, her second daughter won.
What I was looking for in the book was an understanding of Chinese parenting and how it works. What she says is that Chinese parents demand and expect more from their children than Western parents, and this is how they show their respect for their children. Chinese parents begin with the idea that their children are strong and tough, and need to be trained to become stronger and tougher, whereas Western parents tend to think of their children as being fragile, and worry a lot about damaging their self-esteem.
By the time I put down the book though, I realised I am far more of a Western parent than a Chinese one, and I don't really aspire to be a Chinese parent. Amy Chua reports of her struggle, after leaving school, to find what she wanted to do. To please her father she enrolled in courses such as economics, which bored her to tears. It wasn't until later she managed to find a variety of law that she could live with. Even then she wasn't passionate about it, the way her husband is passionate about his work. And I think this is the great drawback, of raising children with obedience and compliance as important values, because it makes it harder for them to look inside themselves and see what they feel passionate about.
Amy Chua points out that Western parents think they are being strict when they make their children practise a skill for half an hour to an hour every day, while Chinese parents know that the first hour is the easy one - it's hours two and three that get hard.
Well on reflection, I don't want to make Jesse practise anything for several hours a day. I do want him to practise basic skills that he is learning each day - half an hour to an hour is fine by me.
When I'd finished the book I realised what it was that I wanted from it, and I got it. I wanted the inspiration to be a bit stricter, and to demand a bit more from Jesse than I have been. I want to raise the bar and assume he has the strength and skill to do what I require. And my requirements are very much a Western Parent's dream, not the dreams of a Chinese parents.
I want him to:
- do his morning jobs without me having to harrass him. You know, the every day things like getting dressed, brushing his teeth and so on. The same with the night time.
- do his various homeschool activities without argument. Yes, be compliant and obedient. I don't need this as a great life value or focus, but for those exercises, like handwriting, ballet and guitar practise, I think it's fair enough.
And that's it. Pretty straightforward.
I was inspired by the Chinese approach to work out a way to achieve it - to demand that he work on achieving these goals at once. Before, maybe I would have gone with a gentle phase-in of expectations, and been much more flexible. Instead, I'm going with the tiger mother approach. I've put up a chart with a breakdown of everything I want, and a star system of rewards and consequences as he works towards achieving it.
Breaking the idea to Jesse was terrible - we had tears and tantrums as he was so daunted by the chart. We postponed starting for a week so that he could get in some practise. This week is official week one.. and it's taking a lot of my focus and energy to be so strict and demanding. Ouch. But I'm hoping we'll get some results soon.. results in the form of a smoother, easier daily routine, with more of my energy left for playing with Jesse and doing fun activities with him.
Anyway, if you've read it leave a comment and tell me your thoughts!