Since I wrote about The Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother, our household has been centred around a strict programme of homeschool which Jesse has to follow.
In the past, when I've instituted a star system, it's been brief and focussed only on achieving one thing. Jesse has generally mastered it quickly and easily, and Paula and I are happy to have such a smooth outcome to the problem area. This time though, the system is long, complicated and daunting for him.
Implementing it has been very challenging for all of us. Paula and I, several times, have been tempted to chuck in the towel, but we've managed to hang in there. Even at the start of week three, Jesse's morning routine, which he has to complete within half an hour, with me giving only a single prompt, tends to elicit mountains of tears, as he is afraid he can't manage it. It's not THAT hard - make his bed (which he's been doing for years), take morning tablets and drink milk, get dressed and put pyjamas away, brush hair, brush teeth. He often misses getting a star because he took longer than the allowed time (ie he got distracted and spent most of the time farting around), or because he thought he'd done it all but missed a key component, or because he'd done half of everything (put on half his clothes, drank half his milk etc). I was starting to despair.
This morning he got up and did it without being asked. I held my breath, didn't prompt him or remind him, just waited to see what would happen. Ok so there was a bit of farting around, but forty minutes later he'd done everything. And then he turned to me and said, "Let's do hip hop."
Several mornings a week we practise hip hop or ballet. After reading The Brain that Changes Itself, I decided that for good brain development Jesse should work on co-ordination exercises like handwriting and ballet. He didn't really want to enrol in ballet - "Can I do hip hop?" he begged - but I said he'd had to. As it is, he enjoys it now, and our home practise sessions are even fun. It only took a few days of the star system to enlist such co-operation in the classes that we are able now, to laugh and make it joyful.
To satisfy Jesse, we found him a hip hop teacher as well - a really fantastic one. He does a private class once a week and it's incredible. The dancing is such a perfect fit for Jesse, and he's so inspired, especially by the ultra-cool Darren, who teaches him. Strangely though, our hip hop practise sessions have been hell. Paula and I contemplated letting him just learn from Darren, and doing whatever he feels like, hip hop-wise, during the week. Afterall, we don't want to spoil it for him. BUT... the classes are expensive, in terms of our time and energy, as well as money. I'm really not prepared to have Darren teach him monkey swing, and then teach him monkey swing again the next week. So - during the week I insist that we practise monkey swing until he can do it properly, so he's ready for the next move. If he doesn't want to work so intensively, I suggested he could see Darren fortnightly instead. But no - he's really keen to learn from Darren weekly.
You'd think with all this motivation, that practising would be easy. But it's been the hardest thing of all. Most mornings we've had forty minutes of arguments and tears as we've tried to work it out, and I keep changing my approach, trying to find a better fit. Finally, yesterday, we had our first really good hip hop practise session. He enjoyed it, he improved, it was fun, it was satisfying! Hooray! And then this morning, he WANTED to practise. He put on music and did a few routines. YES!
Just as I was thinking this whole four-week programme was doomed to failure, it seems to be shifting. We're (hopefully) moving to a place where we can enjoy the structured parts of our homeschool, where Jesse takes responsibility for his daily domestic/personal tasks and attends to them without Paula and me needing to spend half a day harrassing him. In this new place, Paula and I have more time and energy for FUN with Jesse.
A few weeks ago, I was singing a song in German, and Jesse asked what I was doing. When I explained, he said, "Can you speak German?" I nodded. "I'm SOOOO JEALOUS!" he told me. Well I promised to teach him. I got us a German book for kids, and downloaded a German language app onto my iPhone. I've been determined to keep this separate from the star system. I have to keep reminding myself, over and over, this is strictly fun. We are only doing it because he wants to. If he doesn't want to practise, he doesn't have to. This approach is going remarkably well. He's spent a fair bit of time with me recently on the German book, or doing the games in the app, and very often now we exchange a few sentences in German... more and more as he learns more. It's fun. For me, too. This is really why we homeschool - so that we can take on things like this and let them unfold and genuinely find fun in learning.
I actually believe our star system has helped lead us to this place where he CAN enjoy the fun of German. Maybe it would have happened anyway. But I'm not sure. Before I started insisting that he do various homeschool activities, he was in the habit of lying around reading for so much of each day that I started to get annoyed. As a child, I was like that. All my holidays and weekends, I could happily read. So I could understand. But I did think he was turning into a little couch-bound prince, who ate books while the rest of us served him, and I couldn't bear that sense of entitlement. He still reads plenty, and we encourage it, but he's also in the habit of doing other things, which I think is good.